Skip to Navigation Skip to Content
Decorative woodsy background

Why Magazines Still Matter

The conventional thinking in the publishing world is that newspapers, books, and magazines will soon all be produced and distributed electronically. No more inky fingers; everything will be on a Kindle, an iBook, or whatever the latest high-tech delivery system is. I think daily newspapers may indeed be in trouble, but I’m not so sure magazines as we know them are going to disappear. In fact, if I were a betting man, I’d put money on the status quo.

I’m reminded of this as I hold the Summer issue of Northern Woodlands in my hands, more specifically, as I look at Alex Wild’s ridiculously cool photo of an ant eating the elaiosome off a bloodroot seed that’s blown across pages 34 and 35. You can see the picture I’m talking about on our website, but the experience of seeing it in print can’t be replicated. Same, too, for the rest of the magazine, which we’ll trickle onto the web over the coming months.

I guess I have problems buying into the futurists’ vision of an e-world because it seems to me that humans crave more than raw efficiency. Yes, it may be tidier to read several magazines from a stock template on one glowing, plastic, electronic screen, just as we’d all save a lot of time if we just took our meals in Powerbar form or by drinking Ensure. But this seems to overlook a lot of the subtle pleasures of the human experience.

Part of the allure of magazines is the excitement you get when you open your mailbox and find that your copy has arrived. That feeling of anticipation you get while thumbing through things for an initial look – maybe on your porch, with an after-work drink in hand, or with a cup of coffee and the morning light. The way each issue of each magazine has its own aesthetic, its own personality. How a magazine – whether it’s Northern Woodlands or Field & Stream or The New Yorker – sits on your coffee table or nightstand or the back of your toilet and reflects something about you, a design element that brings the house together as much as the kind of tree you plant in the front yard or the art you hang on the wall.

This line of thinking is philosophically akin to the idea that a complete album from a band you love is more substantive and special than downloading a single. In other words, a good magazine is the sum of its parts, not just a part. It’s the synthesis of a thousand different things – the labor that writers and artists put into their prose and images, the interplay of words and design, the thought that goes into the way it’s assembled. It’s the fact that for your money you’ve received a tangible product. Something you can pass onto your friends, keep on your bookshelf, or tear favorite stories out of to give to your grandkids.

I can’t see this going away. Yes, this is my business so maybe I’m nearsighted. But I just can’t see a critical mass of humanity giving up these experiences.

If you’re a reader of this e-newsletter but not a subscriber to Northern Woodlands, sign up today and we'll get a copy of the Summer issue in the mail for you. You’ll find stories on muskrats, bats, and fungi that glow in the dark. There’s an illuminating (and really funny) piece on scientific names; the aforementioned gorgeous piece on ants; the story of the rise and fall of the Brown Paper Company told through the voices of the loggers and mill workers who built Berlin, New Hampshire; a story that, when you’re done reading it, will enable you to explain to anyone who’ll listen why certain two-by-fours at the lumberyard look like propellers; and about 30 other things I could go on and on about.

By buying a subscription, you’re supporting our organization and the cause of land conservation and forest stewardship in the Northeast. By patronizing our advertisers, you’re supporting our tribe. And if your magazine falls into the toilet, give us a call and we’ll send you a fresh copy free of charge. Try doing that with Apple if your iPad suffers a similar fate.

Discussion *

Jun 12, 2012

I think your Powerbar analogy is apt. Powerbars have in no way replaced good-old fashioned suppers by candlelight, but they sure do provide a lot of calories to a lot of people, especially younger people. I think for Northern Woodlands it isn’t a question of either/or but more a question of who we want to be participating in our community. I’m glad that, so far, the magazine and this website co-exist.

Chuck Wooster
Jun 04, 2012

Dave, you and your writing and your magazine are simply wonderful. You caught me reading Northern Woodlands on my porch with coffee in the morning light, and decorating the necessary rooms of my house with previous issues and their glorious covers. And I agree on the need for the printed word.

Adair Mulligan
Jun 04, 2012

Great thoughts on why the print needs to or should live on.  I for one can’t see myself being comfortable trying to read a computer screen of any form while relaxing on the couch or while heading into dreamland.  Plus it’s just plain fun to be able to flip back and forth while reading an article to see the adjoining pictures for reference and besides, what are all the elementary school students going to cut up to make collages while working on learning about history and our fellow beings.  Great job!  Looking forward to the next issue.

dave coulter
Jun 02, 2012

As the debate about print vs. electronic rages around me, I keep wondering: Why does it have to be an either/or choice? There’s room for both. Some material is best served up by one medium or the other; some transfer between. One’s lifestyle and storage capacity influence the selection, as well. It’s wonderful to have so many options!

Carolyn
Jun 01, 2012

I totally agree with your opinions about print magazines. And I relate to your comments about the excitement and anticipation felt when our favorite magazines arrive in the mail. All day I look forward to curling up in bed with my Northern Woodlands or my Organic Gardening or Green Prints or whatever. I have an iPad and MacBook Pro and they are great but they can’t replace a print magazine or real book. Those are some of the real pleasures in life.

Ann Parziale
Jun 01, 2012

Maybe I’m a Luddite, but I, too, feel the need to have the printed copy in my hands.  I read my magazines while eating lunch and dinner and I pass them along after I’ve finished with them.  I’ve been giving my old copies of magazines to the local library for twenty five years or so.

I’m also an avid book reader, spending a couple of hours each evening with a book that I’ve probably grabbed from the new book shelf at the local library.  I keep a list of books that look interesting also and when they’re available at the library I’ll get them.

I do admit to reading the newspaper online.  I have a print subscription as well, but usually tend to give the print copy to my daughter and read the digital version.

Carl A Strand Jr
Jun 01, 2012

Dave, you really know how to put things in perspective, and I’m so happy to see there are other people with magazine addictions besides me. My husband laughs at me, because, as we sit in bed reading, him from his iPad, and me from an honest to goodness magazine (Northern Woodlands of course!), I tell him that never in a million years can he convince me that reading from a lit up screen is better than, as you so eloquently put it, the excitement I get from opening the mailbox and taking out my much anticipated magazine, and finding a cozy spot to read it.

He says that I will eventually succumb to the technology. He’s a technology guru and it’s what he does for a living so he is constantly for it, but I tell him that there is no comparison to stacking your favorite magazines and books beside your bed and flipping through ink scented pages; even the ads are better on a printed paper page. And as you said, there is no tearing out of a favorite article or photo with an iPad.

Eventually he did convince me to switch from my 35mm camera to a digital camera and I even love the photos from my iPhone. (I still think my old 35 mm camera takes better photos!) But he will have to pry a paper magazine from my cold dead hands if he wants to put a 1 lb. piece of lit up heavy metal in its place. Yes,it may save some trees by eliminating printed material, but the love and nurturing of a favorite book or magazine, cannot be replaced with that insane piece of technology.  Call me old fashioned, and I will bask in the compliment.

penelope harris

Leave a reply

To ensure a respectful dialogue, please refrain from posting content that is unlawful, harassing, discriminatory, libelous, obscene, or inflammatory. Northern Woodlands assumes no responsibility or liability arising from forum postings and reserves the right to edit all postings. Thanks for joining the discussion.