Skip to Navigation Skip to Content
Decorative woodsy background

A Monster Red Oak

As we age, we get smarter but we feel dumber, one of those human condition quirks that poets are always pondering. Country singers from Kenny Rodgers on up have lamented the ignorance of youth (“If I knew then what I know now . . .”), but the flip side of this coin is that age brings with it the startling realization that a lot of what you thought you knew turns out to be just plain wrong. Rather than feeling vindicated, you begin to feel insecure and wonder what other bunk you’ve been telling people for years.

These feelings can be particularly acute when you work in media, a profession that involves telling lots of people lots of things all day, every day. Here’s an interesting little story along these lines that happened to me recently.

So there I was in our sugarbush, on a virgin ridgetop that’s never been tapped. The forest is dominated here by 10- 16-inch maples. Interspersed between the maples are – well, were – a few king red oak trees – big, straight fellas with boles that would make a veneer buyer lick his chops. We marked the oaks to be cut, and called in our friend Eddie Legacy to fell the monsters in such a way that wouldn’t take out a swath of young, maple crop trees.

Anyway, the particular stump you see in the above picture was one such tree. It was 32” in diameter at breast height. Two weeks ago, if I had been touring the sugarbush with a school class and was asked how old the tree was, I would have studied it for a second and said: “150 years.”

Seems reasonable, right?

Well, stumps don’t lie, and this big bruin wasn’t a day older than 70. Shows you what good light and a good site can do. The tree also serves as a hopeful message for landowners who are trying to grow big timber – be patient, perhaps your trees are growing faster than you think.

Check out the piece we did in 2007 on where, and why, the trees grow tall, straight, and fast in our region:
http://northernwoodlands.org/articles/article/where_the_trees_grow_tall_and_straight/

Discussion *

Oct 11, 2010

And sometimes it works the other way. We took down a set of 100+ foot-tall white pines growing too close to the house, and we guessed they were 50-55 years old. A ring count of the stumps showed 56 years.

(Of course, we cheated a little—we have photos of the house taken ca. 1950 and there wasn’t a tree to be seen for miles at that time. It was amazing to learn that the entire area, save for farm fields and house sites, has reforested in our lifetime!)

Carolyn
Oct 08, 2010

Oaks can grow really fast compared to other hardwoods, in the right conditions.

Kevin Beattie

Leave a reply

To ensure a respectful dialogue, please refrain from posting content that is unlawful, harassing, discriminatory, libelous, obscene, or inflammatory. Northern Woodlands assumes no responsibility or liability arising from forum postings and reserves the right to edit all postings. Thanks for joining the discussion.